The argument between Amazon and the Big Five book publishers (Hashette, HarperCollins, Macmillan, Penguin and Simon&Schuster) is like watching parents fight. I just want to go outside and play and pretend that my world is not in turmoil. For those writers who have been in suspended animation for the past few weeks, you might want to catch up. You could start with Jeremy Greenfield’s article on this book publishing/selling nightmare at theatlantic.com for 5/28. If you are of great stamina, read the comments that follow. Mom and Dad are very angry with each other and the whole house may fall around us.
Amazon is apparently dragging its heels to ship titles from Hashette because Hashette wants a bigger cut of the profit. The other four Bigs are sitting by chewing their nails because their contracts with Capital A will inevitably come up for renewal and they too will have to negotiate with a company that now controls 50% of all US book sales.
Where do the author and the reader fit into this argument? Nowhere comfortable, it seems. Those of us who publish via Amazon’s Create Space do so for a variety of reasons: creative control, better return on our investment, greater visibility, impatience with the traditional publishers who are slow and who seem impossibly isolated from all but the gatekeeper agents and those authors with a guaranteed following. Yet, the word monopoly makes it hard to breathe. I won’t even play the board game.
I, too, want readers other than the ones in my personal address book. But I also want that creative control that independent publishing offers me. Then there’s the fact that I’m old and getting older. Waiting years for a manuscript to wend its way through that primeval forest of agents, editors and publishers seems sacrificial. For an emerging writer, there is little profit at either end of this cudgel.
While I don’t feel ready to choose a side in this battle of the titans, I plan to keep my ears open to a world gone mad over profit and market share. For me, at this moment, independent publishing makes good sense, but while the “adults” stew and storm, I plan to first write a good book and then figure out how best to offer the world access to that book at its completion.